The spark gap specs for a similar Super200P machine is according to Mark, supposed to be about .030". Check out this thread:
http://weldingweb.com/showthread.php?t=35536
When you have your machine open, check out if the have the same high voltage capacitor arrangement as mine. Note another HF circuit board, has only one high voltage capacitor, whereas mine has two. Two might work better. It would give a different frequency voltage "ringing" in between the sparks.
Also, good idea to straighten your HF points if they are crooked, and sand off any corrosion with emery cloth, a fishing lure file, or similar.
I've tried as low as .02x" and as high as .060" on mine, but have left it for the most part at .030". I haven't experimented with plasma mode in a while, but never really experienced any major problems with arc starting. At the same time, I have a feeling it doesn't work as easily as a newer machine with pilot arc, which I have not tried.
A couple things that I do remember helped me for plasma cutting:
1. use an inline air desiccant dryer in the air inlet (after the filter/regulator thing, and before the machine)
2. use fresh consumables (make sure the electrode and outer metal consumable piece have the proper gap, and are both in good shape)
3. use a shade 5 or so goggles/helmet (not an arc welding shade 9+... it's too dark to see.)
'13 Everlast 255EXT
'07 Everlast Super200P