Originally Posted by
agent4573
Yeah, just went back and looked at it and saw how I was reading it wrong. It brings up another question though, if the 200 is only rated for 160@35%, then whats the duty cycle at 200? Is it even worth while to get a 200 if you actually want to attempt to use 200 amps at any time?
MIG requires that you have some headroom in current. This is because MIG welding is a constant voltage process. The actual current used fluctuates during the weld. Some time ago MIG welders became rated at 35% instead of 60% like most others. I think this was something cooked up by marketing departments, and everyone went along with it so their machines didn't look different from the competitions. If anything I think more MIGs run near 100% duty than any other process. After all no rods to change or other filler metal issues, just pull the trigger and go. So it's up to you to figure out what kind of use you plan to do and what machine will give that to you. For commercial use I still like to have 60% duty minimum, and 100% if the budget will allow. As a hobby machine I'm willing to trade dollars for time, and take some breaks to make life easier on the machine. So no I would not expect to use a job requiring 200 amps with a 200 amp MIG no matter what. You will get clipped power spikes and that is no good for the weld. And if you need that high a power you are talking about welds that matter, too. Maybe a little 120V MIG doing auto body work can max out at times with no big deal, but I don't think you want that at 200 amps.
Long arc, short arc, heliarc and in-the-dark!